Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts

15 November 2026

Evaluating Braxton Bragg after Micro-Teleology Stops

 I watched a good sermon this morning. A distinction of theological significance was brought to light in describing how God is a provider—and was a provider for the Prophet Elijah when God sent him to the Phoenician coastal town of Zarephath to get food from a widow who was on her last ration herself, in what is comparable to the provisioning of loaves and fishes later by the Lord.

The point could be discerned, or perhaps inferred, that the Holy Spirit may provide the feeling or will to act, and the individual makes a conscious decision to follow the emotional or intuitive (cannot be sure of that relation) goad to comply.
Not every emotional or intuitive judgment can be attributable to God, obviously. Yet God may act—or rather, the Holy Spirit may move the individual to a place where provisioning occurs when one decides to follow the will of the Spirit.
I will not even try to explain how the segue to consider Confederate General Braxton Bragg’s military conduct and character during the Civil War—and how different emotional and logical relations of thought operate—is inappropriate for theological points here. Some generals may have prayed during the war for victory or guidance. I think it impossible to point to particular persons and military actions as having been divinely motivated; the spontaneous charge up Missionary Ridge would be as close as I could venture in finding anything resembling divine guidance during the civil conflict. So we can leave off that sort of analysis for the following, which is a response to a chatroom prompt about Braxton Bragg.
I am not a technician of the American Civil War. A general reader of history and philosophy, I have these impressions of Bragg, Burnside, et al. Bragg seems comparable to Burnside in that each were better organizers than actualizers. Burnside’s campaigns sometimes bordered on brilliance, and Bragg’s recognition of Rosecrans’s pursuing over-extension and division of his forces was insightful, resulting in a great plan to trap those elements. After the slaughter at Fredericksburg, when the pontoon assault led to a fighting uphill disaster, Burnside’s Mud Campaign fiasco followed. The plan may have been driven by the logic of emotion—like playing on emotion in chess after losing a piece, abandoning sound tactics for a rash move that almost always ends in disaster. I wonder if Bragg was similarly undone by his own emotional reactions, letting complacency and stubbornness override his tactical judgment after Chickamauga.
Security leaks spoilt the effort to trap Thomas, and also Burnside’s plan to use pontoon bridges to assault Fredericksburg (in addition to weather delays). Longstreet’s arrival at Chickamauga was the operational power of the breakthrough that was delayed by the action of Thomas defending the retreat.
Nathan Bedford Forrest called Bragg a scoundrel and coward for being content with starving Rosecrans out of Chattanooga. Removing Forrest was comparable to relieving Patton of tanks. Forrest wanted to attack rather than starve the 40,000 Union soldiers.
Deciding to wait was a critical error in time, since Grant would arrive to drive out the Confederates in what was perhaps Grant’s most brilliant battlefield action. It reminds me of Caesar’s Alexandrine War.
Bragg’s bad deployment of forces on Missionary Ridge was key in the loss to Union forces charging uphill. A technical point is that the charge uphill after the bottom pits were taken was spontaneous. The troops that fought uphill without orders were the same that had been thrown into retreat by Longstreet at Chickamauga. Bragg was relieved and promoted to military adviser after the defeat. At any rate, he had enough skill to become the military adviser to Davis, and it was Bragg who recommended Hood for the defense of Atlanta.

28 April 2025

Lakers are on the Edge of Oblivion for the 2024-25 Playoffs

 The Los Angeles Lakers are facing expulsion from the first round of the N.B. A. playoffs after consecutive losses in Minnesota to the Timberwolves. It isn’t that they are a bad team or badly coached. The problem is that they didn’t give the elite rim protector and monster of the paint Christian Koloko a regular veteran minimum contract to play in the playoffs and so they have only one tall guy who is fairly slim and a roll player best used against select teams. Another problem is the rookie Coach Reddick. He is good enough yet makes rookie mistakes like playing a 40 year old virtually the entire game so the elite closure scored zero points in the fourth quarter due to exhaustion.

Sitting on the bench was an elite three point shooting rookie Dalton Knecht. His defense is not so hot yet the shooting option was needed for the series. One can’t always know how certain players will perform a priori; one must give them a chance. Coach Reddick wasn’t willing to bring Koloko and Jemenson aboard for the playoff run, and wouldn’t risk winning or losing with a rookie having a supporting role who had similar stats to first year Kobe Bryant, and instead let his team slip to one win versus three losses and the exit door in the floor for the long drop and plop into next season.

The Lakers should keep the coach for he will with luck learn from the experience, not trade Dalton Knecht for a used center, and shop about for a journeyman center without desparation since they have Koloko, Hayes and Maxi Kleber already. If it’s not broke don’t fix it. There isn’t anyone on the team the Lakers should be willing to trade for a center. Alternatively, if a good one appears it wouldn’t hurt to bring a journeyman aboard.





Select Criteria for Building an Electromagnetic Bridge-

  Ukrainians have destroyed a substantial part of the central span (745 feet in length) of a bridge connecting Crimea to the rest of Souther...