Showing posts with label civil war. Show all posts
Showing posts with label civil war. Show all posts

15 November 2026

Evaluating Braxton Bragg after Micro-Teleology Stops

 I watched a good sermon this morning. A distinction of theological significance was brought to light in describing how God is a provider—and was a provider for the Prophet Elijah when God sent him to the Phoenician coastal town of Zarephath to get food from a widow who was on her last ration herself, in what is comparable to the provisioning of loaves and fishes later by the Lord.

The point could be discerned, or perhaps inferred, that the Holy Spirit may provide the feeling or will to act, and the individual makes a conscious decision to follow the emotional or intuitive (cannot be sure of that relation) goad to comply.
Not every emotional or intuitive judgment can be attributable to God, obviously. Yet God may act—or rather, the Holy Spirit may move the individual to a place where provisioning occurs when one decides to follow the will of the Spirit.
I will not even try to explain how the segue to consider Confederate General Braxton Bragg’s military conduct and character during the Civil War—and how different emotional and logical relations of thought operate—is inappropriate for theological points here. Some generals may have prayed during the war for victory or guidance. I think it impossible to point to particular persons and military actions as having been divinely motivated; the spontaneous charge up Missionary Ridge would be as close as I could venture in finding anything resembling divine guidance during the civil conflict. So we can leave off that sort of analysis for the following, which is a response to a chatroom prompt about Braxton Bragg.
I am not a technician of the American Civil War. A general reader of history and philosophy, I have these impressions of Bragg, Burnside, et al. Bragg seems comparable to Burnside in that each were better organizers than actualizers. Burnside’s campaigns sometimes bordered on brilliance, and Bragg’s recognition of Rosecrans’s pursuing over-extension and division of his forces was insightful, resulting in a great plan to trap those elements. After the slaughter at Fredericksburg, when the pontoon assault led to a fighting uphill disaster, Burnside’s Mud Campaign fiasco followed. The plan may have been driven by the logic of emotion—like playing on emotion in chess after losing a piece, abandoning sound tactics for a rash move that almost always ends in disaster. I wonder if Bragg was similarly undone by his own emotional reactions, letting complacency and stubbornness override his tactical judgment after Chickamauga.
Security leaks spoilt the effort to trap Thomas, and also Burnside’s plan to use pontoon bridges to assault Fredericksburg (in addition to weather delays). Longstreet’s arrival at Chickamauga was the operational power of the breakthrough that was delayed by the action of Thomas defending the retreat.
Nathan Bedford Forrest called Bragg a scoundrel and coward for being content with starving Rosecrans out of Chattanooga. Removing Forrest was comparable to relieving Patton of tanks. Forrest wanted to attack rather than starve the 40,000 Union soldiers.
Deciding to wait was a critical error in time, since Grant would arrive to drive out the Confederates in what was perhaps Grant’s most brilliant battlefield action. It reminds me of Caesar’s Alexandrine War.
Bragg’s bad deployment of forces on Missionary Ridge was key in the loss to Union forces charging uphill. A technical point is that the charge uphill after the bottom pits were taken was spontaneous. The troops that fought uphill without orders were the same that had been thrown into retreat by Longstreet at Chickamauga. Bragg was relieved and promoted to military adviser after the defeat. At any rate, he had enough skill to become the military adviser to Davis, and it was Bragg who recommended Hood for the defense of Atlanta.

26 January 2026

Ukraine Conflict is a Trade and Civil War Sponsored by England, Germany, Poland Etc.

 The Ukraine war is comparable to a civil war and they tend toward being the most vicious sort of conflicts. Especially one with the secessionists sponsored by the rich and led by a picked comedian selected by the rich. The war could continue for decades or until the last Ukrainian soldier dies on the battlefield and no more mercenaries or international forces can be found to continue the battle.

The Ukraine war and sanctions on Russia radically disrupt the global flow of trade and prevent the development of new trade routes. It implicitly stops Arctic ocean developments of trade routes and trans-Eurasian land routes from increasing. There is a great deal of wealth made from existing global trade routes, oceanic and cities involved with the present system that would have a new competitor if the war ends favorably for Russia, sanctions end and peace breaks out. From the European point of view controlling all of Ukraine and bringing it into the E.U. would best perpetuate Europe's advantaged position in global trade so far as that remains.  Russia would be filtered out of being a hub for world trade. The United States  would benefit from new trade routes across Russia and on Arctic littoral shipping increases to Alaska.

Russians are generally accomplishing the goal of securing the Donbas, Crimea, Donets, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia and other regions East of the Dnipro in spite of the hundreds of billions of dollars of weapons and military intelligence poured in to prop up secessionist forces. England is the most strong supporter of secession continuing the tradition begun perhaps with their support for Southern American rebels after their invasion of 1812 burning the U.S. capital evolved into a fiasco at New Orleans. France is another supporter of rebels agitating to stimulate and continue the war with its tradition of offing the rich with revolts. The problem is the French themselves are rich these days too, Russians aren't, Poles are paranoid and Germans are legendary evil Krauts lusting to blitzkrieg again.

The U.S. Government has yet to resolve to fully stop supporting Ukraine. Ukraine was generally always a part of Russia from the time of Catherine the Great- no one has a better claim on the much contested over history borderland, and the U.S.A. is rather dense to be involved in that historical quagmire. Russia may produce it's own Suvarov to thwart aristocratic, royalist, fascist or whatever else sort of forces one wants to call them fighting to wrest areas important to Russian security and prosperity away from Russia semi-permanently (until some future round). There are so many emerging threats to the survival of humanity on Earth from the over-the-horizon advances in technology that the war fought these days with drones, counter-drones and hypersonic missiles that the conventional aspect of it seems almost quaint through tragically stupid to prosecute when Ukrainian farmers and urban dwellers would find similar conditions of living when regardless of how the land is apportioned eventually.

Emerging technical weapons with nano-particles, AI and genetic engineering attacks would be slightly more manageable if the Ukraine war were settled amicably and soon. Political leaders working for the west probably have nothing besides greed and avarice in mind envisioning their business developments post war, and profit selling guns, weapons and harvesting body parts for transplants in the meantime. Old Europe probably needs lots of spare organs from healthy young soldiers lost to the predation of drones.

Sexual Auto-Genocide of Philistines Within 200 Years of Making Landfall in Gaza

  The original Philistines were something like marauding Vikings that made landfall around the Mediterranean. One tribe from the original we...