On Efforts to Negate the Anthropic Principle

The anthropic principle seems to have an aspect of Nietchian recursion about it. In physics at least, the conscious awareness of a deterministic evolution in a steady state Universe leading to life is held to be what-true, untrue? Philosophers perhaps would want to examine the terms and language accurately in order to determine what sort of premises are concerned and if they have at least syllogistic validity.

Circular arguments were invented in logic before the era of multi-verse theories; hence the concept may not itself be valid except in a Universe where the geometry is consistent with circles and further that circles traveled return one to where one started in space-time (thus the eternal recursion) as improbable as it seems. I suppose therein is the difference between nominalist points that may be valid outside of space-times as quasi-real tings such as one might regard neo-Platonist nouns in a Kripkian context and the steady state field itself that does not work in reverse presently, nor return the money that typed a circular argument back to the space-time point where he or she started writing it.

I enjoyed reading Tegmark's 2014 book 'The Mathematical Universe'. Ultimately all of the quantum Universe may be no more than pure math. I suppose if one regards Leibnitz's monads as math infinitesimals (tiniest possible points) then one-dimensional monads could be representative of a fundamental quantum structure that would perhaps be equally well regarded as a field of pure thought of God.

Monkeys with typewriters enabled to exist in a deterministic steady state quantum Universe sustained by the will of God might be irreducible to being a circular argument in-themselves even if they evolved in space-time.

Here is a book with some of the topics I wrote on the subject (it's free to download). I am Christian, and I tried to cover many of the questions people have about the existence of God today...

http://www.lulu.com/shop/garrison-cliff ... 99175.html

[quote="[url=http://www.sciencechatforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=291701#p291701]Braininvat » Sun Nov 22, 2015 4:39 am[/url]"]Nietsche's doctrine is eternal recurrence, not "recursion," which is a concept is math and cognitive science.  This confusion of terms somewhat undermines the whole  post.  And "circular" in the thread title refers to a logic structure, not to a spatial loop in spacetime.[/quote]

I have used some philosophical language in my post, yet philosophy is about discovering truth as a kind of wisdom so one wants to write descriptively and objectively even though, or perhaps, while aware of the problem of implicit subjectivity in any quantum observational system (i.e. Heisenberg's uncertainty principle).

Certainly circular arguments were intended by the author of this thread to refer to logical tautology. I was aware of that and intended to place the phenomena of thought and logic within a proper metaphysical context (such as Ortega y Gasset described in 'An Essay on Metaphysics) wherein thought is within a monistic field continuum.

Thought is a part of the physical Universe comprised of extremely complex relationships of neurons with trillions of possible relationships denoting data. There are more possible configurations of connections in a human brain that their are stars in the galaxy. Our Universe is one of four dimensions where circles may exist not only in thought yet also in reality. Einstein's friend Paul Erhenfrest invented the idea that only in a four dimensional Universe could atomic structures exist such as can form life (at least physical life based on atoms and molecular structures) because orbits require  three dimensions of space and one of time. 

Paradoxically max Tegmark; the brilliant M.I.T. physicist expositor of multiverse theory, wrote in his 2014 book ;' The Mathematical Universe', that their may be no actual dimensions of time, and that it could instead be another dimension of space in which every possible worldline or form of atomic structure might be embedded or exist. So there is really not time, motion, or evolution; (I inferred that not Tegmark). Instead human conscious awareness actualizes within a present embodiment of all those possible configurations in 'spacetime'.

The concept is rather advanced. It is also consistent with principles of a holographic Universe as well as a completely deterministic mathematical Universe and one that exists only 'in the mind of God'.

Obviously there are several philosophical approaches to cosmology, epistemology and Christian teleology. It is rare than anyone finds concurrence with others on all of those principles. Modal logic has different theoretical Universes with different laws, and so might any Universe that exists be one within an infinite number of Universes that creates a new Universe each time even one tiny particle (such as a quark) take a different course. The sum of all that infinite number of Universes may be known only to God, as a set of all sets containing itself cannot exist outside of the mind of God (probably).

It is a fun topic to consider the idea of logic, tautology and cosmology. It is possible to create loops that return only negative answers I suppose or loops that return only positive answers in math and cosmology. What if defining any sort of response as positive automatically negated it? I think the problem of certainty that relies on one's own finite knowledge is inherently subject to circularity. It is possible to make infinite reductions of verifications requiring further proof of proof ad infinitum or temporal recursions of logic as loopy[u] go to [/u]statements (in programming) that have an eternal recurrence until the power runs out.

I have thought that Neitschze's eternal recurrence mind experience he had walking along the shore of Lake Lucerne one evening was a cognitive problem stimulated by syphilis. It is possible under stress to view external reality perceived as a recursion, and make an inference that it is infinitely loopy. One may also understand that if the Universe is embedded in an infinite deterministic continuum and that it is actually experience as mind that travels through it (perhaps as a vast atemporal deterministic continuum of God like a neural network structured hologram), Neitschze may have short-circuited his proximal perceptions a little and experience some of the field of infinite permutations of universe and made the mistake of believing it infinitely recurrent without change.

David Stockman's Analysis of U.S. Econ Problems circa 2013 (video)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhigdkNh7a4 The Great Deformation

A Fish Story; Wrangelling Over Salmon Genetic Upgrades

President Obama's F.D.A. approved the sales of genetically fast-growth engineered salmon in the United States over the disapproval of Alaska's Senator Lisa Murkowski who would like to boycott the 'Frankenfish'. The Alaska Bio-Luddite movement has been shocked into a tizzy. Plainly the sale of fast growing King Salmon from a pool in Panama wouldn't help natural grown Alaska salmon that are in declining numbers do to capture on the high seas by foreign fleets.

The approval of genetically engineered fish in the U.S.A. along with the profusion of free trade agreements opens a Pandora's box of nations able to grow and export high-grade genetically engineered fish to the U.S.A. I can hardly wait for catfish the size of whales to grow in Thailand and be trained and directed to swim to American ports for harvest under the guidance of navigation and control brain implants.

In the good old days Senator Stevens of Alaska as a business progressive would have just said go ahead and approve the things universally and Wrangell Alaska would have been the location for the first genetic engineered major fish producer of King salmon to Seattle; location and market position being first being everything, Americans will probably wait until they can buy salmon made ion Shanghai before a super-salmon facility is built at Institute Creek. Hundreds of high-paying jobs will be lost to foreign rivals so Alaskans can listen to the radio and be depressed about job prospects.

I have opposed genetic engineering of bio-forms in the past on principle because it allows random human genomic modifications that cannot be reversed. In the short term though the desirability for women that want their kids to have larger, trophy boobs or short parents that want their kids to be 8 footers able to get that N.B.A. contract may be hard to suppress from becoming political reality.

It is hard to imagine viable prospects for containment of human genomic modification. The first time a researcher produces a gene splicing tweak to eliminate inheritable breast cancer opposition will swoon. If a illegal offshore bio-tank produces a genetic skin color upgrade wealthy Afro-Americans will be returning with Chinese looking progeny.

Genetic engineering is a kind of magic that can let fresh water vegetables grow in saltwater to enhance food supply, or increase brain size, change the structure of neurons in whales to better accomplish mathematical calculations and sundry other presently unimaginable 'weird miracles' of science.

Dr. Frankenstein wanted to create life from dead body parts. Genetic engineering entrepreneurs want to create new forms of existing life by super-sizing good things generally. There are of course some very dark side of the force possibilities in morphing life willy nilly however. So instead of calling growth challenged fish that hate speech term 'Frankenfish' they night better be called 'affirmative growth' fish with the potential to pioneer brave new habitat settlements where no habitats have existed before. Probably an umbrella corporation will own all of the patents on Frankenfish within the concentration of wealth principle. Maybe it should be made illegal to own patents on genetically engieered life-that might be the best discourager of corruption in the concentration of power area.

There are stories of the brave affirmative growth salmon of Panama able to leap tall buildings in a single bound and return hope to the starving, tired and poor immigrating fish yearning to swim free that have yet to be told, and chapters that have yet to be written of the poor little salmon that saw the great waterfall ahead and thought to him or herself, 'I will overcome'.

I wonder how the genie of genetic engineering will be kept in the bottle with so many tech tools available and proliferating as a fairly simply tech. Computers will probably be able to design their own life forms one day so people can grow-their-own new species at home. In a way, space colonization looks better and better as a way to put a firewall between normal human life and the evolution by design Frankocrats.

God, Cosmology and Nothingness (free e-book download)

http://www.lulu.com/shop/garrison-clifford-gibson/god-cosmology-and-nothingness-theory-and-theology-in-a-scientific-era/ebook/product-22399175.html

Quiet Desperation, Muslim Migration and Counter-Cyclical Terrorism

Pink Floyd wrote 'quiet desperation is the English way'. It may be that since the end of the empire they have outsourced that desperation where feasible (i.e. to Russia & the U.S.A.) in order to increase natural resource holdings. When times are not desperate, people still believe what they want, and the rich financing passage through the eyes of needles with nano-camel technology might think wise-guy appeals will work on the final day. Good times may cause error as well as bad. Theology that accounts for individual political events such as terrorism however seems unsupported by scripture. That was actually the point I wanted to get to, since there is so much wrong political hermeneutic on T.V. and in Hollywood even when fiction (e.g. Gabriel and Michael fighting one another with fists and swords). Besides particular prophecy that was historically fulfilled and the expressed will of God or Apostles in scripture secular events and their particular causal relationship to the will of God are only problematically interpreted- what is wise to man being foolish to God, and His will being deep and unfathomable, and the Lord being the light in the darkness; the sole spiritual light in the abysmal gulf of space before and after the stelliferous era. Because human nature is fallen and mankind is wicked and chooses to perp political wickedness, it is grace that is the exception allowing good things to occur. Political evil is more the rule rather than the exception. With free will however, politics occur for temporal, attributable reasons. The Syrian Muslim migrations occurred generally because President Obama accelerated Muslim terrorism and insurrection against the lawful Syrian government creating a very predictable displaced persons crisis. I have written about the way to stop the war being to stop supporting the war for several years. Manufactured desperation is a habit of the advantaged, while countercyclical - adaptation to the vast conventional war and anti-guerrilla war technology of the west seems to elicit terrorism from the faithless, lost and opportunistic determined to war.

Islam and Leftists

A comment made on one of my posts was; "Given the fact that many Muslim nations embody leftist ideology better than America". I think history supports the concept that Muslim nations have preponderantly been anti-communist besides being implicitly theocratic.

Consider the history of the tudeh (communist party) in Iran and Iraq; each were slaughtered after a fundamentalist (Khomeini revolution) or state socialist government (Iraq )took power. During the cold war many Muslim nations were on the side of the west in being anti-communist. Consider Afghanistan and Pakistan in the late Soviet era.

Yet with a history of being an arrested civilization fundamentally in opposition to western democratic traditions (as if much of the left today) contemporary Islam presents a huge challenge for the west to address and defend against.

A wikipedia article describes the history of the  "Dar al-Harb (دار الحرب "house of war"; also referred to as dar al-Garb "house of the West", in some detail. The United States has virtually no history of substantial Muslim immigration. During the cold war we did not admit a lot of Russian communists, nor Japanese during the second world war, nor Eastern Europeans early in the 20th century when they were suspected of being anarchists. The U..S.A. has been able to keep its nation western and democratic because it has a history of defending it against potential adverse demographics. President Obama and the democrat party have worked to defeat that tradition. The U.S.A. has a history of defending itself against adverse ideology such as foreign theocracy and communism from taking over in the nation. Louis Farakhan's 'Nation of Islam' is a manifest reference to a theocratic ideal and entails the appearance of sedition.

Indonesia would be an excellent place to relocate Syrian refugees. then they could present potential security threats to Indonesia rather than the U.S.A. As the largest (demographically) nation in the world that is already Muslim Indonesia easily could absorb a million or two more Muslims without being a kernel of future terrorist growth and security costs.

I don't think that anyone would argue that Indonesia has better freedom of the press than the U.S.A. or that free speech is preponderantly better protected in Muslim nations than the U.S.A. One may view Muslim nations through rose colored glasses, yet they are also largely intolerant of even minority Muslim sects from Pakistan to Iran, Egypt to Saudi Arabia. Islam is a different society with a different history than that of the west, and has been so since its initial wars of expansion and attack upon Europe through Asia Minor, Iberia and Sicily.

One may be naive about the history of western democracy, yet keep in mind that American military aid to S.E. Asia during the cold war is a reason why certain political reforms gained some traction. The American left tend to have no concept of the social requirements for political and social organizations and how they relate to family structure. In fact the idea of cultural anthropology is alien to much of the left that would instead extrapolate American historical experience filtered through new age atheism and Darwinism upon every nation on Earth.

I do not mean to seem overly defensive of western values. It is just the case that I do not have a wish that the U.S.A. complicate its future and create a terrorist base for the next generation as well as trillions and trillions of debt.

http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Dar_al-Harb

Martian Tupperwhere Sweepstakes (satire)

Martian Tuppurwhere Sweepstakes (satire)

The Synthetic Rainbow House of the scenic District of Spindrift announced the next Martian Tupperwhere Sweepstakes today. The winner of the contest to design a 3D printer for deployment on Mars able to make Tupperwhere housing containers for Marstronauts from Y'Earth will receive an all-expenses paid trip aboard a fabulous electro-magnetic mass launcher Mars Luxury Lines shipping container making the voyage from Lunarville to the Martian Moon Phobos' Tupperwhere industrial production facility for a bird's eye view of 3d fabrication.

Because Phobos is gradually experiencing stress fracturing breakdown from Martian gravitational tidal forces and its own irregular shape the Synthetic Rainbow House said Phobos would be given a comfort mesh and an elevator cable-tie to the Martian surface to hold it in place, reduce its nervous stress and take new Phobian arrivals down to Mars. Mars being a planet without rainbows or hope is scheduled to receive its first shipment of little houses on the prairie at the edge of the vast left-wing depression Valles Marineris next year.